Sunday, September 30, 2012
Don't Sit Next to Peggy
If you can throw the farthest, jump the highest, kick the most accurately the playground is your mecca. It also helps to have expensive shoes and clothes with names other kids have seen advertised. Having parents with time and money to cart you to activities helps cement your status. And so it happens I try to convince my children of their responsibility to look out for others, the others who have none of those advantages. They say the same thing, "Mom. It's not like when you were a kid. There is no bullying anymore. They start teaching us about it in kindergarten and never stop. If someone is bullying they get in huge trouble so it doesn't happen anymore." They go back to their happy groups oblivious. I tell them of course it happens, maybe not the obvious pushing and shoving. But they shake their head no and say bullying does not happen. And so, in the middle of the school year, a teacher asked my son if he would sit next to Peggy at lunch. The teacher told my son the whole class to have to sit boy girl boy girl so it would not be noticeable. The teacher also told my son that this girl has issues, and could he try and talk to her, and be nice to her. He came home and told us. He did not know anything at all about Peggy. The first day was uncomfortable, almost like a silent lunch, none knew what to say. My son noticed this girl now. He told us about a world he never knew existed. The kids would tease her quietly and laugh at her. When they walked past her they would say to each other, "ewe, don't touch her! You'll get her germs." and walk away laughing. The second day at lunch he asked her where she lived. She told him without looking away from her free lunch. That was the conversation. As the week progressed they talked a little more, not much more. When he passed her in the hall he said hi to her. His friends said, "Who is that?" He said, "The girl I have to sit next to at lunch." He would talk to us about the situation and we were learning just like he was. Finally, I called the teacher. The teachers knew how this girl was treated. He explained some of the multiple situations that morphed into behavioral problems that made the cycle even worse. The teacher thought if my son could just be nice to her, maybe he could help her in some small way. The teacher was kind. No private information was ever breached, there was no gossip. At dinner, we talked again about our responsibility to help others. My son understood. In his lunch he started to pack 2 of the junk foods we are allow them to pack (gummy bears, fruit roll ups) one for him and one for Peggy. She thought it was a trick, why was he giving her treats for no reason, then she took them. The seating arrangement lasted about 2 weeks and then they went back to their groups. He sat with his friends. She sat on the end or missed lunch because she got in trouble and had to spend lunch somewhere else.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Now that I'm working a part time job at Savy's school, I get to see first hand what is really happening on the playground. It's still the same as when I was in school.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great learning opportunity for your son. He will never know the impact he may have on her life, even though their time together was short.
ReplyDeleteI pray she finds a friend and acceptance.
Hello,
ReplyDeleteI'm your newest follower and your story was very powerful, it seems as though nothing has changed when it comes to how children treat other children at school. It breaks my heart to hear stories like this, but I know they go on every day, that why I always volunteer in my boys schools, so I get to see and hear first hand what's going on.
You should be proud of your son. I think if most kids would have been asked to sit next to this girl they would not of been so kind to her. I am sure that your son's kindness will help this girl.
ReplyDeleteSome times lots of really wonderful children never realize that certain other kids are being left out and mistreated. I hurt for those kids who must be so lonely and miserable.
ReplyDeleteSeems like things haven't changed much since I entered grade school in 1951. We all knew then that if you talked to Ruby, you might get cooties. My mom encouraged me to be nice to Ruby and talk to her anyway, and guess what??? I never got one cootie.
ReplyDeleteI saw this kind of behavior in my middle school every day. I felt so sorry for the "underdogs, " but there was so little that I could do except befriend these kids and let them know that we as educators liked them and would go that extra mile to make them feel more at ease in their situation.
Our school finally realized that there was a stigma attached to getting a "free lunch" so they devised a system where going thru the lunch lines and getting checked in was the same for everyone. It sure helped.
Praises to your son for being nice to Peggy. She'll remember that for a long time to come.
It is sadly the same. I commend your son for trying. Oldest just started middle school and he is having such a hard time fitting in. He said the worst part is when his friend's table is full at lunch and he has to sit with kids he doesn't know. This plagued him for the first few weeks, and one day I asked him if lunch had gotten better. HE said "Yes. I made my own table and now my friends can sit with me."
ReplyDeleteYoungest has always had a hard time fitting in due to his ASD and it always morphed into behavioral issues. One day he was sitting in the school psychiatrist's office and she asked him about his best friend. He said he's his friend because "He likes me for who I am, not what I do." He now has many friends... and his life is so much "easier" because of them.
Such a simple thing, friendship.... makes a world of difference.
Like Jimmie Earl pointed out, it seems things have not changed that much, I am proud your son took time to talk with Peggy and treat her with a bit of respect, most kids are really cruel and having someone treat you nicely is something that will not be forgotten.
ReplyDeleteYour son sounds like a very fine young man who has been raised properly by caring, loving parents. Teachable moments...they come at us all the time, don't they?
ReplyDeleteI'm one of your newest followers; your blog is a most welcome spot for me. Thank you.
Nancy
Your son is obviously a kind, caring person. I don't think bullying will ever stop,sadly...but maybe if more kids show a little kindness, it will be somewhat better for those being bullied.
ReplyDeleteIt seems you are raising a fine young man. Those two weeks may have made a difference in that young woman's life.
ReplyDeleteYou have a wonderful son there, I hope he never changes.
ReplyDeleteVery sad for this little girl. Good for your son to be able to sit with this girl and stand up to peers criticism. The whispers are what really hurts kids.
ReplyDeleteYou wrote this so simply, so directly, and yet I just want to go sob in a pillow for Peggy. Your son is a good kid for trying to reach out. Sometimes, it is the smallest of things that can make such a difference.
ReplyDeleteHaving a child that doesn't look normal or fit in to the normal "status" has opened my eyes to the cruelty of the world. She is in high school now and I would like to tell you that because kids should be a little more mature in high school that it is different , but its not. We have raised her with love and treated her the same as our other kids. She has never complained once to me that she was being made fun of or picked on. My motto in our house was that if you know your family loves you, you can do anything and it doesn't matter what the world thinks. Life isn't fair and sometimes its downright difficult, but its worth it. Thanks for sharing and I think your son earned his wings...
ReplyDeleteAnd sadly there are so many Peggys in schools. In the world. They usually have a story so powerful that is masked in silence or misbehavior. Kids are still as mean as they ever were, especially to those who are somehow different. But all it takes is one person to show compassion. That person will never be forgotten. I'm thankful that your son was able to be that person if only for a short time.
ReplyDeleteAnd sadly there are so many Peggys in schools. In the world. They usually have a story so powerful that is masked in silence or misbehavior. Kids are still as mean as they ever were, especially to those who are somehow different. But all it takes is one person to show compassion. That person will never be forgotten. I'm thankful that your son was able to be that person if only for a short time.
ReplyDeleteThanks for teaching your children to be kind to others...the world needs more parents willing to do that. Too often kids repeat mean things they have heard at home. Thanks for the reminder to be good and kind at every opportunity.
ReplyDeletewe all need to sit nexts to Peggys :)) what a great young man you are raising!! TEASING is teasing not bullying but kids are not learning the difference so they think that they are not breaking rules BUT they ARE breaking hearts.
ReplyDeleteLooks like things haven't changed much over the years, have they? I think the teacher did a good job but stopped too soon. You should be very proud for your son. It was an excellent learning opportunity for him (and Peggy).
ReplyDeleteSo sad that children do this to each other. I'm sure this girl will always remember your son's kindness.
ReplyDeleteYou can be proud of you son for being so kind to Peggy. And I'm sure his kindness meant a lot to her. Both of them learned from the experience.
ReplyDeleteYour son should be commended for trying, regardless of the outcome. Without reaching out and trying, who would ever know what's on the inside of someone, especially one that's different, for whatever reason.
ReplyDeleteI think it's great that your son made an effort with Peggy but it is a hard situation. Sometimes if a child is so introvert it takes a lot to reach them and it needs more than just one person talking to them instead of whispering about them to make a difference. Bullying still goes on a great deal...now the children are just more sneaky about it and use modern technology to take it further than we ever thought possible. I know they teach children all about bullying these days but in a way I don't think this has helped the victims because the 'bullys' are becoming a lot more cunning about doing things without being caught. It's a cruel world and there will always be social, racial, sexual, religious segregations. That's without even thinking about those people with a disability.
ReplyDeleteHave you ever seen the movie, 'Pay it Forward'? I think if you haven't maybe you and your family should watch it...a very moving story.
very nice of your son. this is just to tell Peggy that there are good people out there too. unfortunately bullying happens in some many ways. dont have punch and kick a person to bully.
ReplyDeleteWhat a powerful story! The saddest part is that Peggy will likely continue to have behavioral issues unless someone is able to get through to her regarding her personal worth...at least your son tried. He deserves a "well done" for his willingness and efforts. You should be very proud of him. At least now, his eyes are opened to the real bullying that goes on!
ReplyDeletenice....i imagine your son learned a thing or two....it does happen still, sadly...they do learn about it but that does not change it...it is a lot less obvious though...but it is still there....
ReplyDeleteYour son has a great heart and you have definitely instilled him with values that will last a lifetime.
ReplyDeleteHaving taught for many years, I can tell you the bullying hasn't stopped, just moved to different levels; sadly, social media has seen its share of kids demeaning and degrading others. Kids who bully have issues with their own self-worth and abilities; they are often bullied at home by parents or other siblings. So sad . . .
Here's hoping the situation gets better for Peggy and all those like her.
You have done a good job as a parent, from this story! This is one of the reasons why I am going "back" to homeschooling our daughter. She wanted to give "big school" a try for Kindergarten. I'm thinking she thought the grass would be greener on the other side, so to speak. She is finding that the grass is the same color on both sides, lol!
ReplyDeleteOn a side note, I'm just curious if your son would consider keeping his "new" lunchtime seating arrangement? Continuing to sit next to that girl. Would there be a reason why she couldn't become part of his group of friends?
God bless your son and his kind heart. I do so hope his generous acts sowed seeds in her heart that will give her a lifeline.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great story... I am glad it was your son that was chosen to sit with her....
ReplyDeleteGood for your Son for trying! I know that Peggy will remember that kindness. Have a blessed day dear friend, HUGS!
ReplyDeleteOne of the most difficult parts of teaching is trying to help the child who is bullied or left out. It leaves a hole in a teacher's heart. On the plus side I must say that now that I am retired and so many of my former students are able to reach me via facebook I have been very pleased to see that the children who were bullied are actually all doing quite well. Somehow they found the strength of character to persevere. Unfortunately the children who bullied are not doing as well. Drug abuse, suicide. Makes me wonder where the focus in the class room should be.
ReplyDeleteWell I cant agree more with the comment before me from Fancie M. I can see the children who were bullied during school are doing well better than the children that bullied them. I think it was great for your son to agree and go with the situation and try to help this girl. I wish it happened more in our local schools. We see this even going to university level ragging.
ReplyDeletewww.thoughtsofpaps.com
I have to say...I have been Peggy AND Peggy Sue...being Peggy made me the strong person I am today. Tough times will either make or break you and I always say...fire purifies the gold! Your son's kindness will certainly put a jewel in his crown!
ReplyDeleteWhat a great story. I used to knit mitts for my kids and could make them over night. One would come home and say they lost their mitts and they would get a new pair for the next day. it is only in the last few years my children "fessed up that they were giving their mitts away to the children who had nothing.
ReplyDeleteIt is hard to stand up against the popular mindset, when you know it is wrong. Your son should be commended, and I hope he will continue to extend friendship towards this young lady. Bullying happens everyday and your post demonstrates that kids are just being a bit more subtle about it. I do not understand why kids hurt one another, and as parents I applaud you for your encouragement to your son. I did not find out until much later that my daughter was bullied by her classmates on a continuous basis. Her heart was broken, and so was mine. I do not wish it on any child or parent to go through what we went through with one of our own. It left its mark on her and she still struggles with those hurts today.
ReplyDeleteGood for your son. He'll probably never know the impact he had on this girl's life.
ReplyDeleteAnnmarie, Being a bit of a realist...or perhaps a pessimist when it comes to people, bullying has always existed and will never be eliminated. It may be more subtle now than it used to be, but it is definitely still there...and not just among kids. Adults bully too, especially in the workplace. In the name of 'leadership' Bosses can be the ultimate bullies! In the 9th Grade I was 6' and 200 lbs. and the smaller tough guys always wanted to kick my butt so they could prove how tough they were. When I went to a private boys boarding school, the hazing/bullying was even meaner. I simply told the seniors that if they wanted to try to haze me, go for it...but someone would be injured. They left me alone but over the years, other kids...and teachers too...were bullied or harassed to the point that they left the school. Bullying is wrong but in the end, it's all about Darwin's theory. Take Care, Big Daddy Dave
ReplyDeleteSo true, David. My son was always ahead of his class in height and there was always some smaller kid that would try to provoke him. When he was in junior high there was a situation where a much shorter kid would not leave him alone. I have always taught my children to be the hero not the bully, and this was especially cemented in my sons heart. He would not lift a hand (and he has a very heavy hand) to anyone in anger. It became so stressful that I finally had to go and talk to the Principal. We are lucky that the Principal that we had was a fair and tolerant man who would also not tolerate any bullying. He took care of the situation in a discreet way as to not let anyone know that it was about my son, and this kid never bothered him again. I have to tell you that I do not like getting in the middle of my children's business, I usually let them take care and control, with teachers, students, whatever. I think this teaches them discipline and how to take care of problems, but this time I had to step in and I wish that more parents would.
Deletewhat a wonderful teacher!
ReplyDeleteOh, that's so hard. My heart just aches for Peggy.
ReplyDeleteYeah, bullying DOES happen still. And I was just reading on how you approach it from a Christian point of view. :/ It's tough.
ReplyDeleteAnd this is absolutely heartbreaking.
I want to hug Peggy and go to lunch and sit with her every day. My heart breaks for these kids that feel so isolated from their peers. Glad your son was able to reach out and show her a little compassion!
ReplyDeleteThe teacher saw in your son the quality that he has! Pat yourself and have your husband pat himself on the back for having such a great son! I know this; Peggy won't forget your son.
ReplyDeleteI'm proud of your son! :) Poor Peggy. Rejection is one of the worst emotions ever. The childhood memories will be there until she grows up.
ReplyDeleteWhat a compliment to your son (and by extension, to you) that the teacher would pick him to help Peggy. How sad that people can be so mean to each other.
ReplyDeleteI cannot understand, when a teacher or other responsible grownup sees this happening...why do they not stop it!There will always be mean spirited, bullies..young and old. But in school, the parents should be notified, and some kind of punishment should be administered to the one doing the bullying.A 14 year old girl in our area committed suicide a few weeks ago, because she was being bullied at school.Be proud of your son..and bless you for teaching him the right way.
ReplyDeleteI think bullying has moved from the overt to the covert; texts, social netpages, and the like. I am a High School teacher, with girls from 11 up to 16, from a huge variety of cultures and backgrounds and I think we have cracked the lunchtime situation quite well. All our students, whether they pay for their lunch or have it provided are checked by the same fingerprint scanner, (we have a cashless system where it's paid in advance) they line up according to when they arrive from class, and no-one is allowed to save seats. They sit with whosoever is in the queue with them, which will be different every day. This works. Everyone sits next to someone. Everyone chats; you can usually find something in common with the person next to you, even if you don't know them very well, or don't even speak the same language! We only have 30 mins for lunch, so just enough time for eating, a quick chat and a quick breath of fresh air outside, then back to class. Like you, my parents encouraged us to be friendly to the children who looked to be on their own; we were lucky to have lots of friends, and needed to show these children that they were valued too. Peggy will remember your son's kindness and interest in her as a person, which will surely help her self esteem now and in the future, what a special young man he must be (thanks to you his parents) for his teachers to give him this task!
ReplyDeleteSad.
ReplyDeleteAnd hopeful.
Eye-opening.
School was rough for me as well. A very impressive entry. Will certainly remain in my mind. Strength and patience for Peggy. Deep bow in respect for you and your son.
ReplyDeleteSuch a learning experience.
ReplyDeleteWhat an amazing experience for you son. As a parent, I think I would have preferred the teacher called me first ... but sounds like you were there to encourage your boy.
ReplyDeleteFondly,
Glenda
Ohhhhh it is so true. That teacher chose a nice young man for the interim.
ReplyDeleteChildren like your son Annmarie will help make change in many areas of life both now and in the future.
ReplyDeleteI imagine that you were proud of your son for trying. I feel for the girl though. My Katie (now 17) was being bullied in the sixth grade. She would come home crying everyday and dreaded going to school. I knew what was going on but she refused to name the group of girls doing the bullying. Finally one day she came to me with the names then we went to the principal. It ended that day. Thank God and thank the principal who practiced a no tolerance for bullying.
ReplyDeleteKatie's life at school got better after that.
I commend you and your son. Hopefully his sitting with her may have helped in some way. And I hope that the teacher continues to intervene. Love Di ♥
Diana, I feel for you and know how you feel, as I stated to David up above. If we as parents could just crack that code of I don't want to be a narc and the system would discreetly take care of these bullying children, our schools would be a safer place for our kids to learn.
DeleteWow. So sad for this girl and yet so inspiring to see you son respond like this.
ReplyDeleteWow. What an eye opener all around. There's so much to this story. Peggy and your son were both blessed to have a teacher quietly try to help. I hope Peggy can get the help she so clearly needs and deserves.
ReplyDeleteSad story, and your son was such a good person to try and do what he could. In fact I wonder if there is more bullying now, more insidious and invidious but less the physical bullying that prevailed in our time. Girls especially who learn that ghastly sophisticated eye-rolling and shoulder rolling from TV.
ReplyDeleteThat's nice your son was a good sport about it and learned that there are some kids who need extra attention.
ReplyDeleteHe's touched her life. That's so sweet.
As much as we would like to hope things like this doesn't happen, it does. Kids, un-be-knowing to themselves can be cruel at times. I'm happy you spend time talking to your children and equally pleased that your son made an attempt.
ReplyDeleteThere has always been bully's but maybe this generation can stop it....your blessed with a kind son...who is doubly blessed with a good mom and a good teacher.
ReplyDeleteSuch a powerful story Annmarie and you are a powerful mother who has just instilled something in your sons life that will last him through his lifetime and make him a better parent as well. Which is the key in this story. The bullying starts at home. With a child that is ill-treated by parents or siblings. Where their self-esteem has been ripped from them and they believe belittling other children will make them feel better. Or from parents who just have not thought about the consequences of those little digs that the kids make. "Oh come on my son was only teasing, he didn't hit him or anything". I have taught my children to be the hero's not the bully's and that if they saw someone being bullied it was there duty to try and step in if they thought they could, or at least tell a teacher it was happening. As I told David up above my son has always been on of the tallest in his class, so always someone smaller trying to prove something. We've only had two situations where he had trouble coping with what was happening and one where I believed I needed to step in. The most important thing is that this must start at home with parents talking to their kids about how hurtful this is to do to another human-being.
ReplyDeleteI'm saddened by reading this story. I was bullied as a child, & I'm especially sensitive to anyone being on the receiving end of it. It doesn't sound like a lot has changed since I was young: it's gone underground, & become less definable. Maybe kids don't get beaten up as much anymore, but that doesn't mean anything. Unlike the proverb in the old rhyme, "Names can ALWAYS hurt me." Nothing will change till (as Paula Contreras says, above) the parents of both bullies & victims get involved & put a stop to the patterns that create bullying.
ReplyDeleteYour son did such a great job with this. Hopefully she will see that not everyone is out ot get her or make her life miserable. There are good people in the world too.
ReplyDeleteYOu and your son are heroes. And so is that teacher.
ReplyDeleteSuch a sad story and without a happy ending for Peggy at the moment.
ReplyDeleteSarah x
Hi! You have a great blog. This post was great! I have 4 boys in school and bullying does happen all the time. We have to teach our children the right way. I am part of the blog hop so here is my blog URL : http://fibromyalgia-life.blogspot.com/
ReplyDeleteIt appears that you rarely miss an opportunity to convince your readers that you believe you are wealthy. What a sad and telling pattern of behavior. Studies have shown that people who are financially secure have no need to convince the world of their economic status.On the other hand,those desperately wishing to be seen as such will constantly introduce the subject matter into every possible conversation.
ReplyDeleteand people that post anonymously in order to say something snarkey are bullies...
DeleteNot snarky...just truthful. But I can be snarky. You misspelled the word snarky.
Deleteyep.. but I got bullies right...
DeleteCorrect spelling but incorrect conclusion.
DeleteI mean no disrespect, I'm just making a comment on my interpretation of the post and the comments. I do see your son did a kindness to this girl while it was required of him but I don't understand what all the effusive praise is about. He did was he was asked to do for the required time, but there was not real improvement. I'm sure she appreciated his kindness for the short term, but really he did just what she feared. Tricked her into trusting him and then he abandoned her after he did his time. Believe me, I understand the difficulties and pressures kids face in these situations. I'm sure we can all recall the person in our grade school who was given the same role as this poor girl, and what social suicide it would be to acknowledge a friendship with her. Your son didn't say "It's the girl I sit beside at lunch" he said "It the girl I HAVE to site with at lunch." I don't know what the solution is for this problem. I applaud your son's teacher for making an attempt and the fact that she chose your son to sit with this girl says a great deal about his character, but I can't applaud the results because nothing changed.
ReplyDeleteYES!!! That is why this is such a sad story. Nothing changed.
DeleteThis is a sad story. Your son is very sweet...
ReplyDeleteYour son has a heart of gold, and I thank you for teaching him well.
ReplyDeleteYour son sounds like a kind and thoughtful young man, and I'm glad there are still parents out there who are trying to teach their children kindness and care for others.
ReplyDeleteKids, thanks to anti bullying programs and adult stupidity don't even seem to understand what bullying really is. 'My' kids, after another child looks at them wrong or accidentally goofs up something one is drawing will come to me trumpeting, "John is BULLYING ME!!!!" while they make fun of Lou for having the 'cheese touch'. "Don't let him touch you!! He has the cheese touch!!"
I wrote a post about 5th grade bullying ages ago... http://amimental.blogspot.com/2009/05/5th-grade-education.html
My sister actually pulled her oldest two boys out of school this year and has switched them to an online "public" school they can do from home with her as their "learning coach" for the very reason of bullying happening. Her oldest was bullied horribly during the last two years he was in school. They moved near the beginning of the year when he was in first grade, and since he was "the new kid" it seemed like everyone picked on him because he hadn't gotten established at the start of the year. It was so bad that it was causing similar issues like "Peggy" was having. The following year my sister had to request he be put into a different class than his main bullies (only one of the two was separated so he had to endure one last year as well)!
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, when her next child started school last year, he became friends with the bullying group and instead of standing up for his brother, he joined the bullies and started picking on his brother as well as anyone else this group of "friends" deemed unworthy of kindness. A small amount of "eye for an eye" at home helped keep him in check though after one incident that included a little boy having to wear his sister's hand me down (pink) snow boots.
With all of her children at home and more supervised by adults that aren't being overwhelmed by the sheer numbers of kids, all four of her boys are kinder to others and seem much happier now! They still get to interact with people their own ages (at least the 4, 6 (almost 7), and 8 year old) by attending events held by the school (ORVIS, it's a K12 program) as well as trips to the local parks where there are usually lots of other "home schooled" kids getting in their PE time during the day while the bullies are all in school!
I applaud your son and his teacher for trying...but really I think the teacher needs to do more to address the situation. I've been the Aunt to the kid getting into trouble all the time for reacting to the bullying he/she's receiving (the oldest spent most of his time during 1st grade doing his work in the "time out" room or the principal's office), and quite frankly, spent a good deal of time myself in school in the same situation. I know the school's can't do much to resolve it, but trying always brightens the child being abused by their peers' day just a little bit.
My middle daughter was socially bullied. She was a cheerleader all 4-yrs of highschool, but was an outsider to the cheerleader cool crowd, which was made worse by the popularity of her older sister, also a cheerleader IN the cool crowd. The middle daughter was very shy and socially awarkward, and I had hoped that cheering would burst that bubble, it didn't.
ReplyDeleteToday, all three daughters are best friends with one another... one still painfully shy, one crazy outgoing, and the baby, happy-go-lucky and adored by all. The girls (now 35, 33 and 25) have learned many life lessons from each other... mostly to be tolerant and kind. "Adversity does not build character... it reveals it."